Quan Mai
Jan 17, 2018
visibility 5823
star star star star star
(9 votes)

CartHelper is dead, long live IOrderRepository

As a framework provider, we take backward compatibilities seriously, and we keep supporting public APIs as long as it makes senses. If we can improve our framework by changing the internal implementation without having to change the singatures, we'll go with that.

But sometimes, to improve, we need to leave old APIs behind.

CartHelper is one of the oldest APIs in Episerver Commerce framework, and while it's convenient to use, it has several major drawbacks:

  • It ties to other "legacy" APIs, such as Entry, which are less then elegant to use .
  • It is tightly coupled with the concrete implementation (Cart, OrderForm, etc.), so it's impossible to switch to the new serializable cart mode for better performance. 
  • It is hard, if not impossible to unit test.
  • It always creates new carts if none exists, even if you don't really need them

We already introduced the new abstraction APIs - IOrderRepository, IOrderGroup, ICart... from Commerce 9.19, and fully recommend to use those new APIs to handle carts and orders. New abstraction APIs solves all of the problems above, and yet you have nicer, better looking code. There is no reason to keep using CartHelper now.

In Commerce 11.6.1, we push the recommendation further. CartHelper is now obsoleted and will be removed in a forseeable future - it will be removed in the first major release after Jan 2019.

As always, you should move away from obsoleted APIs, instead of ignoring the warnings with #pragma directives. For CartHelper, the migration path is clear, IOrderRepository is simply the better, future-proof way to go.

CartHelper is dead, long live IOrderRepository!

Jan 17, 2018

Comments

error Please login to comment.
Latest blogs
Finding Thomas Part 5 - The Closed Loop

Five weeks. Five layers. One Thomas. If you've followed this series from the start — thank you. If you're just landing here, the short version:...

Ritu Madan | Jul 20, 2026

Extending the Optimizely Product Recommendations Feed to Include Custom Product Types

A practical way to extend the Optimizely Product Recommendations catalog feed so the export scheduled job also includes custom catalog types, like...

Wojciech Seweryn | Jul 20, 2026 |

Parallel Development in Optimizely CMS SaaS: A Smarter Way to Push Content Models

When Optimizely shipped the JavaScript SDK and CLI for CMS SaaS, they gave developers something pretty cool — a code-first workflow for content...

Vipin Banka | Jul 20, 2026

Fixing index_not_found_exception After Purging External Data in Optimizely Graph

The Scenario: Indexing External Data When working with Optimizely Content Graph, indexing external data is a straightforward process. Synchronize...

Akash Borkar | Jul 16, 2026

Finding Thomas Part 4 - The Intelligence Layer

I've been finding Thomas for a couple weeks now. Bear with me — we're almost at the full picture. Quick catch-up : Thomas is the returning visitor...

Ritu Madan | Jul 14, 2026

The Silent Success: When Your Optimizely SaaS CMS Config Push Succeeds with "0" Changes

  Picture this frustratingly common scenario in headless, code-first development with Optimizely SaaS CMS: You’ve defined a brilliant new element,...

Vipin Banka | Jul 13, 2026