A critical vulnerability was discovered in React Server Components (Next.js). Our Systems Remain Fully Protected. Learn More

Giang Nguyen
Nov 7, 2019
  4618
(1 votes)

Problematic serialization of EPiServer.Url class in CMS 11

What happened?

Recently, I found out some problem with EPiServer.Url objects, mostly because of its serialization.

Let's start with a demonstration like this:

// The page model
[ContentType GUID="..."]
public class MyPage : PageData
{
    [EditorDescriptor(EditorDescriptorType = typeof(CollectionEditorDescriptor<MyType>))]
    public virtual IList<MyType> MyTypeList { get; set; }
}

// The MyType class
[Serializable]
public class MyType
{
    public string WorksNormal { get; set; }
    public EPiServer.Url WontWork { get; set; }
}

// The definition so it won't cause problem with the editor
[PropertyDefinitionTypePlugIn]
public class DecisionItemListProperty : PropertyList<MyType>
{
}

The innocent-look code above seems to be fine and quite simple to most developer. However, there are 2 dreadful error happen in CMS 11 (while it's totally fine with version 10)!

Firstly, the CMS editor's behavior becomes strange when I tried to add MyType objects to the list. Everything is okay in the editor from the popup, workflow, UI. Surprisingly, after saving the page, regardless it's published or saved as draft, every data of MyType.WontWork is gone while everything is saved as expected. No warning or error or stack trace in log file!

Secondly, Find failed indexing the page, every traces point to MyType.WontWork object. I doubt that Newtonsoft.Json seems unable to serialize the Url class (it works okay if [JsonIgnore] is present).

How come?

What I found regards to this is here https://world.episerver.com/features/episerver-features---november-2017/, in PropertyList<T> improvements (Beta removal) section. However, thing there point out directly if the Url class is affected or not, no warn or suggestion for code changes.

I am also awaiting a comment here to help me figure out the root cause of this.

How to fix?

Easy peasy. Just add some annotation to the Url property, so it will look like this:

[JsonProperty]
[JsonConverter(typeof(UrlConverter))]
public EPiServer.Url WontWork { get; set; }

Just that! It would be fine.

Nov 07, 2019

Comments

Please login to comment.
Latest blogs
Jhoose Security Modules v2.6.0 — Added support for Permissions Policy and .NET 10

Version 2.6.0 adds Permissions Policy header support, updates to .NET 10, improved policy management, configurable security settings, and enhanced...

Andrew Markham | Dec 6, 2025 |

Building a 360° Customer Profile With AI: How Opal + Optimizely Unlock Predictive Personalization

Creating truly relevant customer experiences requires more than collecting data—it requires understanding it. Most organizations already have rich...

Sujit Senapati | Dec 4, 2025

Building a Lightweight Optimizely SaaS CMS Solution with 11ty

Modern web development often requires striking a difficult balance between site performance and the flexibility needed by content editors. To addre...

Minesh Shah (Netcel) | Dec 3, 2025

Creating Opal Tools Using The C# SDK

Over the last few months, my colleagues at Netcel and I have partaken in two different challenge events organised by Optimizely and centered around...

Mark Stott | Dec 3, 2025