Try our conversational search powered by Generative AI!

Khurram  -  CMS
Apr 10, 2017
(3 votes)

Content Approvals Require comments for Decline and Approve

This is the last feature in Content Approvals before we remove the Beta tag and make it public.  

This feature allows administrators to configure an Approval Definition with require comments on Approve and/or Decline.



Once this is configured then a reviewer must enter a comment while approving/declining. 

The entered comment is captured and will be used in Approval Notifications.  The Approval Notification email is also changed a little bit in order to present clearly about what has happened and the comment. 

The logged in user will get the same notification instantly with approve/decline comment. 

If the item is the part of the project, the captured comment can be seen in item's activity feed in Project overview


All the comments captured during approve/captured will also be part of the Change log.

There is only one constraint with this release that if the item is not part of the project, then there is no other view/screen where editor can see the comments except the User and Email Notification. 

Apr 10, 2017


K Khan
K Khan Apr 12, 2017 06:45 PM

I have a history behind this question :). In case of truncation of Change log, How Comments will be effected? At few occasion Support have purposed to clear change logs via SQL scripts also. and I have been using those also. Does Project Comments also stays in change log? 

Khurram Apr 19, 2017 10:10 AM

Comments on Projects are part of the change log but if project is not deleted, then those enteries will not be deleted by the truncate job (or sql scripts you are referring). 
Comments on approval/decline are also part of the change log and also saved as part of Notifications. Right now you can't delete a Notification so those comments will be visible even if you clear the change log. 

Joshua Folkerts
Joshua Folkerts Apr 23, 2017 06:29 PM

I love this, only one question, comments are required even though the checkboxes are unchecked. Is this standard functionality or am I missing something.

Khurram Apr 24, 2017 10:54 AM

If checkboxes are unchecked then comments are not required on Approve/Decline.
But comments are always required if you force approve an ongoing approval. 

Joshua Folkerts
Joshua Folkerts Apr 28, 2017 06:46 PM

Can you explain.  I am baffled that both checkboxes are unchecked, but comments required regardless of the checkbox.  How do you now require the comments event if the checkboxes are not checked

Khurram May 15, 2017 09:52 AM

@Joshusa Comments are not required on Approve/Decline if the checkboxes are unchecked. 

But there is a functionality called "Force Aprove". Only an admin can "Force Approve" an approval sequence, in which case the entire approval is approved at once. If an admin utlizes this functionality, then the comments will always be required regardless of checkboxes. 

Verese Desder
Verese Desder Jul 12, 2018 12:00 PM

Must see Must see Must see

Please login to comment.
Latest blogs
Optimizely Web... 6 Game Changing Features in 2024

If you are interested in learning about what's new within Optimizely Web, you are in the right place. Carry on reading to learn about the 6 greates...

Jon Jones | Mar 3, 2024 | Syndicated blog

Headless forms reloaded (beta)

Forms is used on the vast majority of CMS installations. But using Forms in a headless setup is a bit of pain since the rendering pipeline is based...

MartinOttosen | Mar 1, 2024

Uploading blobs to Optimizely DXP via PowerShell

We had a client moving from an On-Prem v11 Optimizely instance to DXP v12 and we had a lot of blobs (over 40 GB) needing uploading to DXP as a part...

Nick Hamlin | Mar 1, 2024 | Syndicated blog

DbLocalizationProvider v8.0 Released

I’m pleased to announce that Localization Provider v8.0 is finally out.

valdis | Feb 28, 2024 | Syndicated blog

Epinova DXP deployment extension – With Octopus deploy

Example how you can use Epinova DXP deployment extension in Octopus deployment.

Ove Lartelius | Feb 28, 2024 | Syndicated blog

Identify Azure web app instance id's for an Optimizely CMS site

When running Optimizely CMS in Azure, you will be using an instance bound cloud license. What instances are counted, and how can you check them? Le...

Tomas Hensrud Gulla | Feb 27, 2024 | Syndicated blog